If you haven’t heard of Sally’s baking addiction before let me introduce you:
https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/
She is one of my top favorite bakers and like Cookiesandcups she also has some stellar cooking recipes, this being one of them! I found this back when she first posted it and have made it every year in the fall/winter since. My whole family loves it! Yes, it has a ton of butternut squash in it and if you are nervous about it – don’t be! Mac ‘n cheese is suppose to be orange anyway so no one will know the difference haha. Also, squash is a type of vegetable that is pretty bland so it soaks up whatever flavor you add to it. In this case, its yummy cheesy goodness. If you are nervous about it tasting “pumpkin-y” then lower the amount of squash to 3.5 or even 3 cups and keep everything else the same. Be aware that it may have a pumpkin smell to it PRIOR to baking – don’t let that freak you out. It bakes away and leaves pure goodness behind.
Now, as you will see here at Sugar & Stice (have you caught on with the joke yet…sugar&sTice not sugar&sPice…cause my last name..hehe..) I will often post recipes from other bloggers and instagramers and show you how you can really tweak each recipe to fit your own taste. It is something that I have done over and over again. I will first make a recipe pretty much step by step and then I will start to develop my own tips and tricks to make it more functional and filling for my family.
I hope that seeing this gives you the courage to do it for your family. Often times I hear my friends say that they tried a recipe and they liked it okay but not enough to make it again. The way I see it they are only on the first step to a family favorite! Use that first time as a stepping stone to tweaking that okay recipe into a great one! Because for some, trying something different in the kitchen is a big deal and I would hate for he or she to waste all that effort and leftover ingredients when greatness is within grasp. Now don’t be fooled, I’m going to give you some recipes that are straight up bomb exactly as written haha so be looking forward to those!
K so here is the original recipe with her screenlicking good pic:
https://sallysbakingaddiction.com/cream y-butternut-squash-mac-and-cheese-with-kale/

I can almost taste it when I see that picture 😋 but go ahead and click on the link and see what you think – you may want to make it exactly as written but here are my changes:
TIP 1: I use spinach. I rarely, if ever, have kale on hand so this is better for me. I also use sharp cheddar and a little grated Parmesan on the top (not the powder kind).
TIP 2: I add chopped ham into the mixture before pouring into the 9×13, like a cup or two. So this is a good recipe to use up the leftover Christmas ham that’s coming up next month!
TIP 3: I like to dump half my mixture in the pan, sprinkle with some plain or Italian breadcrumbs, then dump in the rest of the pasta mixture and top it with more breadcrumbs and a sprinkling of cheese. This is a pretty creamy dish so adding that little bit of crunch in the middle really added something extra for me.
TIP 4: If you don’t have Greek yogurt you can use sour cream, laughing cow light Swiss cheese, or even cream cheese like Sally mentions in her notes. Or honestly if you don’t have any of those and really want to make it you’d probably be fine leaving it out since it’s only a 1/4 a cup for the whole 9x13inch dish. If you have it though add it cause, yum!
Along those lines don’t be afraid of having to switch similar things. Like if you don’t have penne pasta but you have rotini – go for it. (But be aware of elbow macaroni – that is one pasta that is hard to use in substitution for other larger noodles. Since it’s so small if you try using elbow in place of, say, penne, you will end up with way too much noodles and a dry dish) If your family doesn’t like spinach don’t add it but maybe serve buttered peas on the side. Or leave out the spinach completely and let your family think they aren’t eating any veggies with dinner -jokes on them mwhaha!
FINAL THOUGHTS:
This dish is a family favorite. The first time I made it as written and we really liked it but my husband was still craving meat (men, whatcha gonna do lol) and I was feeling like it needed more of a crunch. So instead of stopping there and never making it again I did those few little changes and I got a yearly family favorite that I look forward to when the leaves start to change color in the fall. It’s healthy, from scratch, home cooking at it’s finest. I hope you’ll give it a shot and let me know what you thought in the comments and whether or not you tweaked it to be your own.
Till then – Jenny




